User login |
Women and the EgoI've been enjoying Eckhart Tolle's class on Oprah.com very much. I was not blown away by his book A New Earth, but I find Tolle to be absolutely heartwarming to watch. One of the things Tolle shares in A New Earth is his belief that women are not as susceptible to the ego as men are. Well, Tolle, I appreciate that you revere women so much, but as a female I beg to differ. Never mind my own fantastic, stubborn ego. Ego is at work in many women in our culture today, as we focus on our looks instead of our brains, our bodies instead of our hearts, and our appeal to men instead of our appeal to ourselves. Take fashion magazines. Who on earth invented these items of mental torture? I for the life of me cannot figure out why women purchase these sinister publications of Satan, but they do. I never saw the point of staring at women who were better looking than me. Maybe it's because I was the geeky kid wearing glasses growing up - I somehow missed the indoctrination that popular teen girls get into fashion and make-up. Granted, I did purchase a few copies of Tiger Beat back in the day, but the whole purpose of that was to plaster my walls with pictures of Def Leppard and John Stamos. (Yeah, John Stamos. As in, when he was on General Hospital John Stamos. I think I had good taste at 13. John Stamos is still seriously hot more than 20 years later...not that I should focus on male appearance in an article suggesting we stop focusing so much on female appearance, ahem.) Tiger Beat used to just be about cute boys - on viewing their website, they seem to be a training ground now for obsession with all things celebrity. Hillary Duff gets as much coverage as the latest boy group. Yes, that's progress. Once an indoctrinated young woman grows up, she then can join the "sophisticated" adult world of high fashion. Female television shows such as Lipstick Jungle promote this obsession with the "right" clothes and "glamorous" make-up, with one of its leads a fashion designer and prominent Maybelline product placement throughout (apologies to Jungle co-star Paul Blackthorne, who recommends Tolle at his much more conscious website). The fashion world has become this bizarre caricature of itself where pretty much anyone can create a line of clothing provided they are shallow and famous...as in, Nicky Hilton and the might-as-well-be-strippers Pussycat Dolls. The girls on the runways get younger and thinner, and no amount of media attention on their eating disorders seems to change the basic focus on the Lolita-like aesthetic. We women feed the horrible media machine by purchasing tabloids, clicking obsessively on celebrity gossip websites, and charging up clothes we don't need on credit cards. We actively purchase and consume things that make us feel inferior, less-than, and not good enough. We then go out and buy the products that are supposed to fix these feelings of inferiority. We singlehandedly keep the American economy going through our insecurities. Why do women create this hell for ourselves? Our egos. The simple reason for this is that young, attractive women get a high off of male attention. Maybe when we were young, our egos got a boost when a man looked our way, even if all he was seeing was our body and not our souls. So we then want to recreate that high, as much and as often as possible. Or, if we didn't have that happen, we saw girls around us having it happen and we wanted it for ourselves. We want that fake "power" that we believe we have when we "wrap a man around our finger." But really, what's happening is that we've lost our power. Any time we need to look towards a man for our sole validation based on our sex appeal, we've now debased ourselves and men. (Because now we've fed into the male ego and his need for validation by having an attractive female as a possession or as arm candy. Some men do unplug from this, though, so let's not insult them by assuming they are all shallow.) Why is it that lesbians seem to achieve more than straight women in the creative arts? I don't think it's because they somehow have a gene that makes them so. I think it's because they don't care about male attention. I have struggled with this myself. I have gone through periods where I courted (and got) a lot of male attention because it made my ego feel really good. Then one day a male friend of mine, who I had known for years, told me in no uncertain terms he would not hang out with me unless I had sex with him. He wasn't even interested in dating me. He just had decided that he was tired of having female friends and no sex. At that point, I reversed course and decided I had had enough of male attention, that it wasn't really all that meaningful. As I have pursued my spirituality more, I have found no need to go out and get men to look at me. Sure, it's nice when it happens, but I really feel it's not necessary to make me feel good about myself. The only man I need to have paying attention to me is the man I marry. The rest can go about their business. Why do I want a man who is all about how I look anyway? All that means is that he is into me based on his ego, not his spirit, and our relationship is built on quicksand. It will end unless firmer foundations are built. The only true foundation to a lasting relationship is a deep spiritual connection and commitment based on unconditional love. Thankfully, I grew up relying on my brains and so I do not have the misfortune of many women who were pretty all their lives. One woman called up Tolle on the second installment of his class on Oprah. She was very lost, because she was now aging and was losing her beauty. It is a gift, actually, to not be beautiful, because you learn how to cultivate other aspects of yourself. And yet, we all want to be beautiful. Our ego tells us that is the answer, that it will fix our problems and make us more loveable. But the ego is a trickster. And it's wrong. Beauty is only skin deep, but the soul transcends all that. It takes a lot to let our egos go. The first step for women is to wake up and notice how our entire culture is set up to make women consume themselves. And then once we realize we're being brainwashed, to unplug from it. Awareness is of course the key. |
SearchPollFeelosophySuccess in any area often creates a spirit of entitlement — 'I deserve this' — that is the exact opposite of servant leadership. It is evidence of insecurity and low-self esteem. Insecure people show off. Secure people serve. Recent comments
|
Eckhart Tolle and Women
I can understand why you disagree and I do also see many women who are in the throws of the ego, including myself. But I think Tolle is speaking to a bigger issue. Women have been considered second class citizens for a very long time. I am dismayed that we cannot get a national conversation going about misogony or sexism but it doesn't matter. It exists, even if people don't want to see it. The facts are;
almost all women are raped or abused in their lifetimes, 80% of all the people who live below the poverty line are women and children, and that 1 out of every four women are in an abusive relationship. The stats are even worse in other countries.
I think these facts speak for themselves. We are not a minority, we are half of the population. Our children are not protected properly and neither are we. Raising children should be valued work. Maybe if we stopped having babies, the government would realize that life is something to be revered and respected, not sent to war or thrown in jail.
I'm not so worried though. t may have to get worse before it gets better. The burden will fall on women to change it and I can't wait. Who better to change the world? Women are the most innovative, multitasking, hard working, creative, and cooperative people on the planet.
Those that oppress women should be worried.
We're all in this together
You state that "almost all women are raped or abused in their lifetimes, 80% of all the people who live below the poverty line are women and children, and that 1 out of every four women are in an abusive relationship. The stats are even worse in other countries."
I'm not sure where you got the statistic that "almost all women are raped or abused." I have not been raped or sexually abused, and I doubt that "almost all" women are. Of course, this is a huge problem, but I don't think it helps to speak in hyperbole about it. Not just women are sexually abused either: One only needs to look at the debacle of molestation in the Catholic Church to see that young boys are also often victims.
The reason why I'm questioning your statistics and focus on "women as the victims" is that I don't think it helps the cause of women or men either when we are put into opposing camps. "All women are victims and all men are oppressors" is an easy ego-based label that women can use to make themselves feel superior to men. Let's not forget that mothers also hit and abuse their children, and that men also suffer from the gender stereotypes in our culture.
I have had wonderful, supportive experiences with many men in my life and horrible, unsupportive backstabbing experiences with many women. Both men and women can be wonderful and horrible. I do not think that women are better than men nor do I think that men are the sole perpetrators of negativity upon the other gender. Men may statistically perpetrate more outward violence but there are other types of violence, including emotional abuse (perpetrated by mothers upon sons, for example).
Rather than making it a man vs. woman thing, let's look at how we can create a culture where abuse is less likely to happen, to either gender, period. But trying to make women out to be the untarnished victimized heroines of a horrible plot by men to oppress them...that is precisely the ego of women speaking.
Eckhart Tolle
I think you are right. I will continue to struggle with my anger but I'm making progress. Dealing with my own issues of bias and bitterness are my top priority.
The statistics I talked about can be found at many resources including the National Crime Stats website. I know some will change from year to year but trends are overall the same. Here is a link to the most recent.
http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/pdf/cvus0501.pdf
Most organizations that come up with these stats agree that rape stats are lower for both genders than they should be because men and women do not report it.
I find it frustrating that most people aren't aware of how bad things have gotten, let alone how bad they have been. I agree that men are also victims of all types of abuse and that they suffer greatly under gender stereotypes.
Actually I am more worried sometimes about what is happening to them.
Women are now graduating from high school and college at higher rates all over the country. Male babies are more prone to defects from environmental pollutants, and in a handful of countries, the gender ratio is shifting because female babies are more likely to live under more severe conditions i.e. famine, drought, high altitudes etc etc..
Autism seems to be imprisoning 1 out of 100 babies and most of them are male. Not to mention the thousands and thousands of families already dealing with the loss of a father, son, mother or daughter from the war. Our soldiers will come home and battle with debilitating injury and PTSD which can lead to domestic violence and addiction.
I am alarmed though.
If you are pregnant women in this country, the most likely way for you to die is at the hand of the man that impregnated you. Statistics on paternal I am alarmed at our raunch culture where torture and abuse are entertainment, particularly when there are things you can do to women in pornagraphy that aren't even legal to do to a dog. I am alarmed at the stats concerning child abuse, pornography and human trafficking. How do these things affect the way men view women and how does that carry over into behavior? Of course this debate has ensued before in the 80's, in front of Congress (Andrea Dworkin), but nothing has changed. I'm only talking about the United States. I try not to think too much on everything I know about what is happening to women all over the world, because I just cry.
My perspective is very different from yours. Every member of my family has suffered, sexual or physical abuse, including myself. I have a wide spectrum of people in my life and most of the beautiful and talented women I know are victims of abuse. Of the men I know, the numbers are no where near the same. I was raised with brothers who played soccer which meant I had 20 brothers. I felt privileged to know so many men intimately because it has given me better understanding of them. I study them as much as I study so called "women's issues". I love men. I have personally loved a few crazy, beautiful ones but those aren't the reasons for my views.
I am just paying attention all the time.
I want men to know these issues as well. I am a scientist and educator and its important for me to tell people that these aren't just women issues, they affect everyone. The reason I focus on women is because I think it will be women who can make real changes, if just one thing happens....
We can come together...
Women absolutely must stop judging eachother and start having compassion for one another.
From another great spiritual leader
....If nonviolence is the law of our being, the future is with women...
- M. K. Gandhi
if you are interested in more literature please let me know... thanks for responding...
J.
Glass Half Full or Empty?
In response (your comments italicized):
The statistics I talked about can be found at many resources including the National Crime Stats website. I know some will change from year to year but trends are overall the same. Here is a link to the most recent.
http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/pdf/cvus0501.pdf
According to those stats, less than 1 out of 1,000 people or households was a victim of rape. The actual number was 0.8 out of 1,000, which is a heck of a lot less than what you seem to be suggesting.
I find it frustrating that most people aren't aware of how bad things have gotten, let alone how bad they have been. I agree that men are also victims of all types of abuse and that they suffer greatly under gender stereotypes.
How are things worse than they ever have been? Women can now go to college. Blacks don't have to sit on the back of the bus. We have a black man and a white woman as the top contenders for the Democratic presidential nomination. Things are better and have been improving, and in a very, very short time.
Autism seems to be imprisoning 1 out of 100 babies and most of them are male.
You presume that people with autism are miserable and living meaningless lives. I've seen many happy autistic people being portrayed in documentaries. They can function and often live very fascinating, purposeful lives. Don't assume that disability means your life isn't worth living.
Not to mention the thousands and thousands of families already dealing with the loss of a father, son, mother or daughter from the war. Our soldiers will come home and battle with debilitating injury and PTSD which can lead to domestic violence and addiction.
And yet, these soldiers chose to do this because they are taking part in something that is bigger than themselves. Don't presume for them that their lives were wasted: They chose that path and it has meaning to them. Death is either nothing (literally) or it is eternal life. Death is also part of life. So dying in and of itself is not the greatest tragedy.
If you are pregnant women in this country, the most likely way for you to die is at the hand of the man that impregnated you.
Hyperbole, and not true. Medical complications are the number one way to die if you are pregnant. Furthermore, while homicide is still a top reason why pregnant women die, men aren't the only ones doing the killing. Other women (jealous of the pregnancy) are also perpetrators of homicide against pregnant women. See:
http://abcnews.go.com/US/LegalCenter/Story?id=522184&page=1
Statistics on paternal I am alarmed at our raunch culture where torture and abuse are entertainment, particularly when there are things you can do to women in pornagraphy that aren't even legal to do to a dog.
And yet, women in America choose to act in porn all the time. No-one stuck a gun to their heads. They wanted easy money or fame but they chose to do it. Adult women who choose a career of pornography out of their own free will are not victims. They made a choice.
My perspective is very different from yours. Every member of my family has suffered, sexual or physical abuse, including myself. I have a wide spectrum of people in my life and most of the beautiful and talented women I know are victims of abuse. Of the men I know, the numbers are no where near the same.
Well, I can't honestly say that most or hardly any of the women I know have experienced this abuse. They've experienced the normal run of issues and problems, such as daddy not loving me enough after the divorce and stuff like that.
Could it be that perhaps you are consciously or subconsciously seeking the friendships of women who share your victimization?
I am just paying attention all the time.
Apparently so, but only to everything that is wrong and horrible in the world and not to anything that is good and right.
Think about that for a second.
Women absolutely must stop judging eachother and start having compassion for one another.
I dunno, sometimes I think it is appropriate for women to judge and say "hey, your selfish behavior is hurting other women." Or, "hey, wake up and find more meaning in life than a Prada handbag."
Ultimately, I don't mean to give you a hard time here but to suggest that you have put on grey-covered glasses and are spending your time focusing on every possible horror and atrocity as a reason to see the world as an awful place for women.
Well, here's what I think. I think people are surprisingly resilient. I think that people can overcome a lot. And I think we do a huge disservice to people by suggesting that they can't live happy, fulfilled, productive lives just because some rotten thing happened to them in their past. Yes, this includes childhood sexual abuse as well as rape.
We all have experienced crap in our lives. I've experienced a chronic illness. OK, I could sit here and whine and moan about it and be angry or I could do the best with what I have and appreciate the positive things in life.
Byron Katie does some truly radical work with sexual abuse. It is very controversial, and not politically correct. But people do get healed from it, instead of carrying it around like a badge of hatred for the rest of their lives.
http://www.thework.com
The first question to ask might be: Women are oppressed...is that true?
I think, perhaps they are not, at least not to the point that you seem to think they are.
Love is the law
Here a link to an article that has a different perspective on pregnant women than the one you offered
http://www.courttv.com/trials/peterson/090304_pregnantmurder_ctv.html
This website has a lot of world stats and US stats for abuse
http://www.endabuse.org/resources/facts/
Thank you so much for the dialogue, it was very enlightening. Your website is wonderful, thanks for the forum.
“Love is the strongest force the world possesses, and yet it is the humblest imaginable”
Mohondas K. Gandhi
J.
This is an interesting
This is an interesting dialogue between the two of you.
From the sidelines, I would have to mention that Stephanie sees that the world is a better place for women, as she is a successful woman who has never been abused.
JCE, however, mentions that the world is still a horrendous place for women, and comes from a pained and possibly abused past.
I feel that I am both of you and from the center I will verify that yes, Stephanie, you are right. It's great that as a *minority* female I am able to be college educated, successful and currently living a happy and peaceful life.
JCE is right too however. I've been abused in the past and almost all women I meet have been in one situation or another. I decided that it wasn't anything to dwell in when I realized that almost all the women I shared my "story" with had something similar to compare or top. It's a sad world when an abuse becomes something of the norm.
If you're asking me for the point, I would say I have none, except that it's interesting that you two have vastly different views and yet are two women living in the same world.
Universal responsibility
I too am a woman and considered a minority and I would consider myself reasonably successful. I am in my last year of graduate school and will finish with a PhD in cellular and structural biology. ( I hate when they lump special interests groups into minorities and women. Woman are not a minority, we are half of the population.)
The point I was trying to make does not mean that I dwell on my difficult experiences or that I seek those that do and focus on the negativity of the world. All the women in my life are reasonably successful as well and have endured extenuating circumstances. The world is a beautiful place filled with wonderful people. I have been blessed from birth, mainly by just being born in this country. I try everyday to enjoy my life to the fullest and marvel at it. Science has helped fuel my curiosity my whole life.
Stephanie makes a lot of assumptions about my ideas that are not true and not what I was trying to convey. But no matter. I cannot explain everything in my heart. I ache for those who suffer and feel it an obligation to stay informed and participate when I can. I feel it is even more our obligation because we are so blessed with opportunity in this country. This is the point I was trying to make and I think issues that people call women's issues, like domestic violence or birth control, are not just women's issues but affect everyone. This issues are largely ignored and this is frustrating to me. Our great spiritual leaders have always said it better than I can:
I believe that to meet the challenges of our times, human beings will have to develop a greater sense of universal responsibility. Each of us must learn to work not just for oneself, one's own family or nation, but for the benefit of all humankind. Universal responsibility is the key to human survival. It is the best foundation for world peace.
-His Holiness the Dalai Lama
Thanks Shelly and Stephanie so much for your attention and comments. I really appreciate the discussion.
J.